Why a fallback option is your best bet

The other day I had to get a car insurance for my wife's car and I initially went with a broker I already knew pretty well and got a quote. Then I realized I should just for piece of mind get a second quote. I called up another broker I knew well and got 40% cheaper deal right off the bat. And this broker wasn't doing a counter-offer - he just presented me with the best deal he could find. These are the moments that make me appreciate the "fallback" option. It really pays off.


When it's a long term commitment - always have at least 2 options

I know it sounds like common knowledge but it's not - I remember in so many cases that I blindly relied on just one option when a long-term commitment was at stake. Especially if it's a long-term financial deal - two options means you have a choice. Like a real choice.

Even when you rely on people you trust - it's about your interests after all

When we do business with people we trust, it's a good practice to ask around or "shop around" as they'd say in America. The people you trust are good people - no doubt about that - but they might not pay enough attention, have enough contacts, or knowledge, or simply are too busy with something... having a second option makes you prepared and ready. It's your interests after all, not so much theirs.

Doing homework is not a wasted time

When I was trying to get a mortgage I went to two brokers and got two different deals in two different banks - and one broker told me that they couldn't get me the bank I wanted but the other got me the deal somehow. They didn't know they were competing - they both thought I'd only work with them exclusively.

Moreover the broker I chose actually advised me to go with two different banks and see which one finally makes the deal. Again, it was a wise move and proved my point. I got the best deal with the best (and fastest) bank.

Yes, it takes more time to deal with two people but it pays off. Time is money but if you're negotiating a financial long-term deal. The investment of a few hours now pays off in years and years going forward.

Not telling the other party you have a plan B is not bad - it's sensible

Business is business and you're expecting the other party to do a great job. I'm a catholic and (hopefully) an ethical person an I always want to be sincere with someone I'm dealing with but what I learned is that when you tell them "I'm also negotiating this with this other company" they'll either start ignoring you or they'll be mad at you or they'll just stop working for you. The atmosphere of competition instead of motivating them, has a counter-effect.

That's why I don't tell the other party that I'm having a fallback option. If they ask, I don't lie, but they never ask. I'm expecting them to deliver me a great job or great offer and if they can't - I have all the right to have another option. After all, it's in my interest in the first place.

What do you think? Do you always "shop around"?  When?

I'm Michael Sliwinski and I'm an entrepreneur who's also the...
.. Founder of Nozbe.com - a time and project management web application
.. Editor of Productive! Magazine - a global PDF publication on productivity
.. and a blogger as well as a producer of a weekly 2-minute Productive! show.

Posted on Monday, November 14, 2011 (business)

Like this post? Subscribe to my newsletter, and every 2 weeks you'll receive updates from me. You'll also get you my latest book for FREE as a thank-you: "No Office Apps: How the Nozbe team uses modern technologies to communicate better and get more done.".

Nov 15, 2011 07:41
It is a very strange phenomenon that there is a rather small corelation between the amount of money that you've spent on something and the quality of the service.
Michael Sliwinski
Nov 15, 2011 16:14
It's really strange that although you're going to spend a lot of money on something, you very often get bad service thus you need a second choice to make sure you're not being ripped off. Great point you've raised, Testeq!
Nov 15, 2011 17:07
Hi Micheal.
Very interesting post. But most people doesn't think in this way. They tries to apologize themselves "I don't have a time to look for another option", "this looks good I'll take it" But in most cases after all, they're disappointed of their choice etc.
But when I'm comparing a two offers, I try to be careful and ask a particular question: Is it possible to get exactly the same for less money? It's not difficult to take a two offer and choose this cheaper.
So I think when we look for an good offer we should in first describe what exactly we want. Then it will be easier to answer is cheaper offer give us exactly what we want :)
Michael Sliwinski
Nov 15, 2011 19:34
It's not only about a cheaper option, but a better option. In the post I quoted a cheaper deal but it's all about having an option and going for a better deal (whatever "better" means to you) - thanks for rising this valid point, mrdoro - I haven't highlighted it enough in my post - you're also right that people go with the only option they have and almost always regret it later. Thanks for your comments!